Skip to content
Tutela Ed Academy
← All case stories

Composite: based on real situations; names and details changed.

The April surprise

Maya, D1 volleyball player, 21 · Volleyball · College

MoneyTaxes

The setup

Maya had the season every athlete wants. Her team made a deep tournament run, her following tripled, and the deals kept coming: a local gym, a regional restaurant group, a couple of apparel posts, some autograph signings. By December she had made about $38,000.

Every payment landed in full. No forms at signing, no money held back, just deposits. She covered rent, sent some home, bought a used car and figured she was doing great.

The turn

In January the tax forms started arriving. NIL money is usually paid to you as an independent contractor, which means nobody withholds tax for you. Between federal income tax, self-employment tax and her state’s tax, she owed about $6,500, plus a small penalty for not paying during the year. She had about $1,200 in her account.

How it ended

It was stressful, not the end of the world. A tax preparer her school’s NIL office pointed her to found deductions she’d missed (travel to signings, a ring light, part of her phone bill), which brought the bill down some. She set up a payment plan for the rest and paid it off by summer. Now about 30% of every NIL payment goes straight into a separate savings account the day it lands, and she pays estimated taxes each quarter.

What to take from it

  • Assume nobody is taking taxes out of NIL money. Set aside a share of every payment the day it arrives; many athletes use 25–30% as a starting point.
  • Keep receipts for anything you buy for your NIL work. Real business costs can lower what you owe.
  • Tax rules vary by state and by situation. Talk to a tax professional early in a big year, not in April.

Learn more

Rules vary by state, school and association. This story is education, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to your compliance office and a licensed professional.