Composite: based on real situations; names and details changed.
20% and the passwords
Marcus, D1 baseball player, 20 · Baseball · College
AgentsContractsBrand
The setup
Marcus hit three home runs in a weekend series and his phone blew up. One message stood out: a marketing agent who said he could get Marcus “six figures by next season.” They met for coffee and the guy had a contract ready.
The terms: 20% of all NIL income, including deals Marcus found himself. Three years, renewing automatically. And the logins to his Instagram and TikTok so the agency could “manage the posting schedule.”
The turn
Marcus didn’t sign at the table. He asked a teammate with an agent what his deal looked like: a lower percentage, only on deals the agent brought in, a one-year term, and nobody else touching his accounts. He also checked whether the agent was registered in his state, which some states require. He wasn’t.
How it ended
Marcus sent back a counter: a lower cut, only on deals the agent sources, one year, a 30-day exit, and no passwords; the agency could draft posts and Marcus would publish them. The agent stopped replying. A month later Marcus landed two local deals on his own with help from his school’s NIL office, and kept 100% of both.
What to take from it
- Agent fees vary and there’s no single right number, but you should never pay a cut on deals you found yourself unless you chose to.
- Never hand over your passwords. Your accounts are your brand, and losing control of them can take years to fix.
- Check whether an agent has to be registered where you play, and walk away from anyone who rushes you to sign.
Learn more
Rules vary by state, school and association. This story is education, not legal, tax or financial advice. For your own situation, talk to your compliance office and a licensed professional.